Friday, June 22, 2012

The Diving Bell and the Butterfly

In CPE, we watched the stunning movie "The Diving Bell and the Butterfly" about a young French socialite (Jean-Dominique Bauby) who has a stroke and is almost entirely paralyzed inside his body.  He is unable to move at all, except for blinking his left eye.  It's a humbling story to watch, as he struggles with feeling trapped, with realizing he's now incapable of atoning for past wrongs, and with simple things like a buzzing TV that he can't turn off.  Eventually, his speech therapist devises a laborious communication technique whereby she lists all the letters of the alphabet until he blinks to choose one.  Letter by letter, he is able to write the book "The Diving Bell and the Butterfly" to tell his true story, the one on which this movie is based.  We're required to write a short theological reflection for class, and here's mine:
 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Why, for what reason, does God love me? Perhaps every human wonders this as they change, growing in some faculties and losing in others.  It’s easy to assume that God and other people love us for the strongest or best faculty we possess at the moment – maybe helpfulness or generous service, a strong work-ethic, a quick intellect, or a kindly spirit.  Yet all these can be stripped away.  I’ve seen it happen with my grandmother these past few years, as her once lively body and good-natured mind become dull with pain and bitterness.  And I saw it in the “Diving Bell and the Butterfly,” in Jean-Dominique’s frustrations and shifting emotions.  Underneath all these changeable capacities, there must be something deeply true to each human that God recognizes and loves even when we can’t pinpoint it.
The fact is that I didn’t much like the character of Jean-Dominique Bauby even when he did have all of his faculties.  I thought he was arrogant and inconsiderate, too enamored with his own playboy ethos as well as cruel to the mother of his children, Celine.  I don’t understand why he was surrounded by so many female ‘beauties’ throughout the movie; it was unrealistic to portray him as having some magnetic pull to attract these women so desperate to spend time with him.  Yet in any case, people did love him and there was something of God’s grace in that.  Even though he had been absent a lot, the children still kissed and loved him. Even though he could only blink, the speech therapist and book translator loved him in their own ways too.  Hence the movie testifies to the grace of being loved even when it isn’t deserved and can’t be earned.
As paradoxical as it seems, I believe that this most passive faculty – this fact of being loved by God and, by extension, loved by others - is what makes us who we are.  For whereas I have a hard time letting Jean-Dominique off the hook for being such a cad to Celine, I know that grace is true when I consider other, more forgiving cases.  For example, I know a family with a baby who died a few weeks after birth.  The family grieved and how they wondered at the unfairness of God in starting his little life just to end it: What was the point? The baby never did anything at all, couldn’t even manage to pump the blood through his veins.  But at some point in arranging the funeral, someone suggested to the mom that the baby did have something, and the one most important thing: the capacity to engender love.  For every short minute of that little blue and dying boy’s life, he was engendering love in the heart of God and all the family gathered around.
In ministry, I find it helpful to remember that any given person’s essence – whatever makes them who they are, as a distinct human loved by God - is located on a level deeper than faculties.  For if God loves both the dying baby (who couldn’t do anything for himself) and the jerk husband/father like Jean-Dominique (who did too much for himself), then God must be engaging souls on a level that I can’t comprehend.  It’s one of those things, yet again, that the intellect, the emotions, the will and all other perceptive faculties, etc.  just can’t touch.  And in a sense, I find that freeing - for I don’t have to know why God loves a given patient; I just have to trust that God does, and then aim my pastoral love towards that deep, quiet and imperceptible place in the soul where God sees the fullness of who they are.  For God knows each person better than they know themselves, and certainly much better than I ever could.

No comments:

Post a Comment